So, on to my thoughts. These students argued with each other so much. They were mean and cutting to each other. I can't tell you how many hurt feelings and sad faces I saw in the 2 hours I was there. At one point, I actually told the kids to stop. They said this was normal. I told them that they fight worse then brothers and sisters do and that they needed to look around and realize the damage that they were doing to each other. They didn't get it.

Justyn told me last night that he is no longer friends with a girl that has been his closest friend this entire school year. Having just experienced the attitude of this class, this comment did not surprise me. I asked him why not. He said that she told him 'she was A class and he was D class and so they could no longer associate with each other. It was too damaging to her social image.' He said he told her they were 4th graders and that she was being silly. She didn't agree. She has to look out for herself and for her future and so no matter how well they get along or what their past relationship has been, they can no longer be friends. I was surprised and kind of dumbfounded at this point. I asked where she could have gotten such an idea from. He said she read it in a book.
What do you tell your child at this point? My first response was to tell him she was mean and cruel and that she was D class, not him and to stay away from her! Who needs her anyways. Then I rethought my response and decided to handle this like a mature mother and not a spoiled, hurt child. Instead, we talked about why people tear others down. That usually it means they are insecure with something about themselves and that while I don't think he has to put up with being treated that way, I expect him to still be kind. If he looks around him, he will probably find that others are being treated the same way and that maybe, if he befriends them, he will find out that they are pretty cool also, just l
ike he is. We decided that he can prove he's "Class A" by not returning her cruelty.I've often thought about social classes. I've never thought of myself as "Class D" but never "Class A" either. Probably "B" or "C". As I teach my children, I am slowly seeing things differently. While I like the idea of high-society, is it worth the cost? If "A" means that you have to shun others and put others down in order to lift yourself up, then I would rather not be apart of that. And why can't we classify each other based on good works and kindness rather than money and clout. I want my children to grow up respecting themselves and the world around them. I want them to find happiness in serving and in making their world better and more beautiful because they were in it and not in cutting and tearing others down. Why do we have to be so hard on each other? I know, they are only 10 years old. They are still kids. But seriously, is this too much to expect? And am I doing enough to lead my children by example? At this point, probably "Class D" is about right.

My only thought at this point is, I'm so glad that summer break is two days away!
15 comments:
Hi Laurie,
Sorry I haven't stopped by lately. I can't get a feed for this site since it's private and if a blog isn't in my feed reader, I'll forget to check it sometimes. I need to be more diligent in remembering.
I thought this was an excellent post and what an example of how you handled the situation with the "A" class girl. I mean, what kind of crap is that? I would be ready to react in the same way you first thought of reacting. I definitely need to practice thinking things out. I think you handled the situation beautifully!
Hmmm. I think you handled it right with your son. There's something about 4th grade girls-that's the age when some of the girls in my class started to get really snooty too. There are several books out right now about girl-aggression and how the way our society treats women actually encourages this type of behavior (usually targeted to other girls, not boys.)
What sort of books is this girl reading???? I think you handled the situation beautifully Laurie! how lucky for you that summer break is here!! my kids have their winter holidays at the end of June!! and I can't wait.. two weeks of not having to iron uniforms, make lunches but most of all not having to get up early when it's dark & so cold!! I hope you all have a fantastic summer break!! take care..
Tanya xx
This is disturbing, though not surprising. Ethan has a "friend" who is constantly mean to him in an effort to inflate himself. And he is mean to Kate as well and I don't even need to say how this mama bear feels about that. I have had to get after him and he gives me the "I was just kidding line." I say, "No, you aren't kidding, you are being mean and I won't have it in my car." The older I get the braver I become. This sort of thing is out there and will be forever. I try to communicate with and educate my kids and also love, love, love them so they have a "socially safe" place to go. My two cents. . .
I think that you did the right thing. It would have been my first reaction also to just say "who needs her anyway!" But I think that you handled it perfectly. You are the one that gets to help shape and mold your kids into the kid of people they should become. I think that with the help of the Savior, you will guide them in the right direction.
As for social class, you are an A in my book! Love ya!
I think you handled it well. I've had similar discussions with E because he has a couple of friends who like to build themselves up by putting others down. It's usually subtle, but it's there. He understands that they do it because they are the ones who are insecure.
When I think back to my elementary days, I remember girls being so cruel and I remember being left out of things.
It's sad, really.
I agree that you handled that well. Kids can be so cruel and thoughtless. I worry so much about what my/our kids have to go through these days. It's great that he could/would talk with you about it.
I too am way excited for summer.
Kids are terrible sometimes. I don't believe it is just as it was when we were younger, I think it's worse. Different parenting. Girls are just starting all that terrible crap in about 4th grade. They don't usually need help from a book. All we can do is to be there for our kids and teach them kindness, self-worth, and how to be strong. Hold on. I'm afraid it will be a long ride - for all of us w/kids.
I'm just amazed at the way you handled such a hurtful issue. I think I would have been the mom that says, "She's not worth your time...just forget about her." Way to go Laurie!
Kids these days can be so hurtful to others! I think that you handled that situation very well. He'll learn from this situation and just like you said he can seek out others that may be being treated the same way. He could be just what one of those kids in his same situation needs. Something good could come from the situation!
I guess he has to learn about "popularity" sometime. I have a favorite quote from a tape I used to listen to when I was a kid/teenager (I think it was the soundtrack from a play), called, "Debbie, Diary of a Mormon Girl".
"Why would you want to be popular and have just a few friends, when you could be unpopular and have many?"
I'm glad you taught him to not only continue to be kind to her, but to seek out those who don't have friends and are lonely. What a difference we can make in the lives of others if we always build them up and not tear them down. There is a great quote by Pres. Hinkely about that, too, but I will have to look for it.
Kindness, pass it on!
WHAT? that is crazy! the craziest part of it all is that eventually, everyone grows up and it DOESN'T MATTER. unless you live somewhere like beverly hills.
sorry he had to experience that. i can't even understand it, forget imagine trying to explain it to one of my kids. jeesh. you're a good mom.
I remember elementry school, kids can be so mean to each other. I have a super sensitive little girl and I worry about her tender heart. I hope I can teach her that the most important thing is, How you see yourself!!
What kind of parent lets their kids read such books?! What the heck. Makes me think of the place in the Book of Mormon where the poor were shunned and looked down on because they didn't have fine clothes and were told they couldn't worship God....the cycle repeats itself.
Post a Comment